Let's Make Robots!

Razor IMU - 9 Degrees of Freedom - Has anyone used it?

Hello People

I wonder if anyone has any experiance with the Razor IMU with 9 Degrees of Freedom from sparkfun. Is is value for money?

I have found one here http://proto-pic.co.uk/9-degrees-of-freedom-razor-imu-ahrs-compatible/ at what seems a very reasonable price as far as UK prices are concerned (£72 + 6 shipping). Some places are mad expensive, up to almost £120...

Anyway, still in the vein of attempting to give my bot some more brains than simply non-collision movement I am looking at gyros, accelerometers and magnometers. Hoping to figure out a fairly accurate method of DR.

Does it make sence buying something like this with the 3 different components on one board + a dedicated AVR 328 processor or would I be better off buying the components seperately? Arguments either way would be appreciated.

Cheers

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I see, you might then consider pololu's miniIMU-9, which doesn't have a brain but is less than half the price of a typical "smart" IMU

Hmm... in the end I have decided to go for a magnometer/accelerometer combo for £22 over here http://www.hobbytronics.co.uk/lsm303dlh-tilt-compass?keyword=compass

I decided that saves £40 for right now. Maybe when I am ready for the gyroscope I will buy a gyroscope breakout or the 9 DOF if I really need it.

So my DR for now will consist of angle turned + time traveled at pre-measured speed... simple but my research into DR using INS indicates this is not a trivial subject.

There is an open source project where they are looking into INS navigation - specifically for flying vehicles... http://www.openpilot.org/products/openpilot-coptercontrol-platform/ which I will be watching. Seems the INS maths is *really* hard.

 

 

I think in part it depends on how much time and experience you have.  If you don't have experience with accelerometers & gyroscopes, surface mount soldering, PCB layout and circuit design, expect to be at it for awhile, to learn a lot, and to save possibly nothing depending on your costs: boards/components/shipping/possible equipment and defects from learning.

I can only assume you are talking about dead-reckoning, but it always helps to spell it out.

Hi rogue

I was more talking about buying seperate modules already on seperate breakout boards as opposed to buying the components and doing all the soldering myself.

I have done that for an arduino clone and also a motor controller, but for the 10-15 pounds I saved I took a good 10-15 hours to do it... design, solder, test etc. learning experiance but at a rate of £1 per hour it certainly was not worth it in a strictly financial sense.